DMUG-Archiv 2020

Frühere   Chronologischer Index   Spätere
Vorherige   Thematischer Index   Nächste

[Dmug] Gleichheiten, die es nicht geben sollte

Liebe Freundinnen und Freunde des Zählens,


In[94]:= (* correct *)
RegionMeasure[Point[{672, 125}]]

Out[94]= 1

In[95]:= (* correct: dimension is 0 - RegionDimension counts *)
RegionDimension[Point[{{672, 125}, {672, 125}}]]

Out[95]= 0

In[96]:= (* still correct: number of points *)
RegionMeasure[Point[{{672, 125}, {672, 125}}]]

Out[96]= 1

In[97]:= (* now dimension is 1 and R. E. Ference says: "RegionMeasure \
corresponds to curve length for one-dimensional regions:"*)
RegionDimension[Line[{{672, 125}, {672, 125}}]]

Out[97]= 1

In[98]:= (* wrong: counts points instead of giving the ArcLength in dimension 1 *)
RegionMeasure[Line[{{672, 125}, {672, 125}}]]

Out[98]= 1

In[99]:= RegionMeasure[Region[Line[{{672, 125}, {672, 125}}]]]

Out[99]= 1

In[100]:= ArcLength[Line[{{672, 125}, {672, 125}}]]

Out[100]= 0


the latest and greatest

------------------------------------------------------------------------
In[101]:= $Version

Out[101]= "12.2.0 for Microsoft Windows (64-bit) (December 12, 2020)"

------------------------------------------------------------------------

has the curve length of a single point line equal to 1 and some more Monty Python results can be obtained:


In[102]:= RegionMeasure[Line[{{Missing[]}, {Missing[]}}]]

Out[102]= 1

In[103]:= RegionMeasure[Line[{{Null}, {Null}}]]

Out[103]= 1


Missing[] and Null seemingly considered as identical points, but in principle RegionMeasure knows what to do:


In[105]:= RegionMeasure[Line[{{"Hans"}, {"Oderhauer"}, {"weiss"}, {"nicht"}, {"was"}, {"ein"}, {"Punkt"}, {"ist!"}}]]

Out[105]= Sqrt[("Hans" - "Oderhauer")^2] + Sqrt[("ein" - "Punkt")^2]

+ Sqrt[(-"ist!" + "Punkt")^2] + Sqrt[("nicht" -  "was")^2]

+ Sqrt[(-"ein" + "was")^2] + Sqrt[("Oderhauer" - "weiss")^2] + Sqrt[(-"nicht" + "weiss")^2]


Mit den besten Grüssen

Udo.


_______________________________________________
DMUG Deutschsprachiges Mathematica-Forum demug@XXXXXXX.ch
http://www.mathematica.ch/mailman/listinfo/demug
Archiv: http://www.mathematica.ch/archiv.html

Frühere   Chronologischer Index   Spätere
Vorherige   Thematischer Index   Nächste

DMUG DMUG-Archiv, http://www.mathematica.ch/archiv.html